CDA Challenges USGG Position
By Metal Center News Staff
on May 23, 2023
The Copper Development Association is challenging letters sent by the U.S. Geological Survey to congressmen and senators, denying a bipartisan request to immediately add copper to the official Critical Minerals list due to its dramatic supply risk.
“Despite clear data showing that copper’s supply risk score is now above the threshold for automatic inclusion on the 2022 Critical Minerals list, USGS sent well-crafted letters to a bipartisan group of congressmen and senators filled with misleading arguments that were not part of its own official 2022 methodology, or consistent with the spirit or letter of the law, to justify a decision to forego immediately adding copper to the list," said Andrew G. Kireta, Jr., CDA’s president and CEO. “This decision was made even though Secretary Haaland has the authority given to her by statute to add copper to the list, without waiting for the next update in three years.”
Unlike in Europe, where copper was recently added to its proposed Critical Raw Material and Strategic Raw Material lists based on forecasting future supply and demand projections, USGS addresses supply risk with a rearward looking analysis that does not address current and forward-looking policy demands that can leave domestic supply chains short of critical materials. USGS’s last official evaluation for the 2022 Critical Minerals List is based on copper trade data that represents supply risk from 2014 to 2018, five to nine years out-of-date, and too old to be meaningful. Notably, USGS did not refute the CDA study showing copper’s updated supply risk score is now above the 2022 threshold of 0.40.
“Continued supply trends and solid data confirm that the supply risk for copper is not a short-term issue that will self-correct without determined, immediate and strategic action,” said Kireta. “We must ensure that America’s manufacturers and supply chains have ready, reliable, economic access to copper to meet the growing demand and policy goals for a cleaner electrical grid, a lower carbon economy, and a strong and resilient defense sector. CDA calls upon Members of congress to not accept USGS’ decision lightly and to undertake all means and measures to address this ill-conceived and unfounded decision.”